A Sad State of Affairs...Alabama's New DUI Statute Destined for Failure Once Again

On September 1, 2012, the substantive provisions of the DUI ignition interlock statute take effect. The new law made several changes to the existing DUI statute, such as requiring an ignition interlock device for offenders who refuse to submit to blood alcohol analysis or those who submit to testing with a result of .15 or above. But as history teaches us, each time the Alabama legislature endeavors to "get tough" on DUI, they end up achieving the exact opposite result. Case in point? The 2006 Amendments. In 2006, the Alabama legislature attempted to close a loophole that had developed in the law: Prior DUI convictions in municipal courts, as well as out-of-state convictions, could not be counted as prior offenses for sentencing purposes, as the legislature had not properly worded the statute. So, the legislature specifically stated that prior convictions in municipal courts or from other states would count for sentencing purposes. But in doing so, they accidentally used language from another portion of the statute, and stated that prior convictions "within a five year period" would count. This had the effect of forgiving all prior DUI convictions that fell outside the five year time frame. Hundreds, if not thousands, of offenders were immediately affected by the change. Many facing felony (4th) DUI charges with lengthy potential prison sentences were transformed overnight into first time offenders, as their prior fells outside the five year time frame. The legislature never admitted the mistake, and amending the statute to take out the "five year" language would be an admission of their incompetence, so shockingly, the language remains in the statute today. The 2012 Amendments are similarly riddled with loopholes and drafting errors, not to mention that the State is woefully unprepared to institute a statewide interlock installation program. As a result, the appellate courts will be flooded with a series of challenges to the new statute in the years that follow that will demonstrate the legislature's incompetence yet again.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us Today. Free Consultations.

Call our office today at 205-453-9700 to talk with one of our lawyers for free. You can also fill out our online contact form.

Send Us An Email

How Can We Help You?

The personal injury attorneys at Simms & Associates will be happy to provide you with a free evaluation of your case. Please provide the details here, or feel free to call to speak to a knowledgeable and experienced injury lawyer now.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Simms & Associates
608 37th St South
Birmingham, AL 35222

Phone: 205-453-9700
Fax: 205-251-9940
Birmingham Law Office Map

${site.data.firmName}${SEMFirmNameAlt}

Contact:

Location: